I love what John E. Smith (@StratLearner) has to say about this topic. It’s closely related to a previously-mentioned post of mine that’s still in the works. As L&D professionals, we need to be aiming for “deep learning” but it seems that our efforts often wind up only getting to a more superficial level; an issue that speaks more to overall implementation and adoption issues, rather than a specific ID fault.
What’s most telling for me is the opening quote. Read it, and you’ll see why.